Johnny5Bench has seen its share of great pitchers. Ronald Piazza with 6 cy young awards leads the cast. Richard O'Neill has won the award 4 times. Other multiple award winners include Burt Saipe, Alton Meulens, and Weldon Hughes. Season 8 saw an unusual co-winners in the AL. Here is a List of all winners:
Season 1
NL-Ronald Piazza, Hicks
AL-Steve Washington, Mechanics
Season 2
NL-Ronald Piazza, Hicks
AL-Burt Saipe, Dudes
Season 3
NL-Ronald Piazza, Hicks
AL-Richard O'Neil, Sabres
Season 4
NL-Ronald Piazza, Hicks
AL-Alton Meulens, Express
Season 5
NL-Burt Saipe, American Kings
AL-Alton Meulens, Express
Season 6
NL-Vern Russell, American Kings
AL-Richard O'Neill, Sabres
Season 7
NL-Ronald Piazza, Hicks
AL-Richard O'Neill, Sabres
Season 8
NL-Weldon Hughes, Paw Sox
AL-Gary Simmons, Sabres
AL-Barney Drese, Bay City Bullies
Season 9
NL-Ronald Piazza, Hicks
AL-Richard O'Neill, Sabres
Season 10
NL-Todd James, Angels
AL-Greg Price, Sundance Kids
Season 11
NL-Weldon Hughes, Paw Sox
AL-Chili Hooper, Bay City Bullies
